« Ten marketing lessons from the Barack Obama Presidential campaign | Main | Downsized? Fired? Here are the new rules of finding a job »

November 11, 2008

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451f23a69e2010535e64ee1970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Answering the ultimate question: "How do I convince my boss of the ROI of new marketing?":

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Ari Herzog

ROI measurement by pants and leaf blowers. I like it, for I deal with those MBA types frequently.

@Stephen

What is the ROI of golfing with clients? What is the ROI of an executive retreat to a spa/resort?

You are correct in that there is a new set of returns to be measured, and the old cliche "50% of our advertising doesn't work, we just don't know what 50% it is" is going to be proven false - as we learn which 50% is effective.

Simply Mike

As usual David, you cut thru the gobbledygook and use commin sense.

I actually like the cynical parts too ;-)

Steve Johnson

This is a really good video. One rant that I would add is this: measuring leads and clips isn't effective--AND NEVER WAS. We've been measuring the wrong things!!! It's like asking "How much did you enjoy your vacation?" and answering "31 MPH."

justin

great stuff as always david. only comment, i clcked on "more" at the end of the video and got nothing! pooey! wanted more! :-) - jl

Tom Lindstrom

Good video.

jacqueline

I highlighted YOUR blog in my Blogs.com Top 10 Small Business Marketing Rock Stars Blogs! Thank you for what you do!

Kevin Clancy

The ROI of putting on your pants...now that's funny.

It's true that there are different motivations/objectives for doing different kind of marketing programs, the cost of which of doing are likely much less than the time, effort (a.k.a., headaches), and cost required to measure them. So like putting on your pants, it may not pay out to track the investment back to a sale--you don't want to be cold when you go outside and everyone else where's pants, it's that simple.

I did cringe a bit, however, that giving this kind of response to senior management would send an implicit message that there just is no way to show new media and different "alternative" marketing communications has a positive effect on sales and brand equity. Not to mention, "Just trust us with the money, we know intuitively that it works" isn't going to fly with CEOs and CFOs who are under the gun--especially now during a recession--to show a profit and are likely eyeing the marketing budget as a place they can save some dough.

You seemed to be getting at this point in your comments, but I thought I'd reiterate that the real problem with measuring isn't the measuring part. With all the technology and sophisticated models out there, you can measure pretty much anything in marketing. Even with new media, there's likely a way to "monetize" it one way or another.

The real problem with most ROI tracking today is you get numbers but no relative basis of comparison to show if they are good or bad or what to do to improve them.

Recall the reason marketers are gravitating to new media is because there was this sense old media--advertising, print, radio--wasn't working. New media with less clutter and a lot of positive buzz seems like a viable alternative, but at the end of the day, the same questions still lurk.

Brian Anderson

The major deficiency with MBAs is that they have never been in reality-land - direct sales - so they don't understand how to separate the meaningful from the meaningless.

In general, we are in a state of enormous change and a lot of folks are in denial: why? Because they're no longer in control of the accepted and unquestioned levers of ROI drivers (golf pun?). It's like that old saying about truth with the first of three tenets being that "it is violently opposed."

The comments to this entry are closed.

@DMScott


Your email address:


Powered by FeedBlitz

follow me


David Meerman Scott books


I want to speak at your next event!


Newsjacking!


David Meerman Scott e-books

David's iPhone and iPad apps

Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 12/2004