« Social media (finally) makes its way (slowly) into the closeted world of Investor Relations | Main | Weasel words, gobbledygook, jargon, buzzwords, babble, blather, and baloney »

September 14, 2008

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451f23a69e2010534a9850f970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Don't ruin your great YouTube video with too-slick Madison Avenue packaging:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Dave

Hi David,

You are right. I went to the Great American Roadtrip site and at first I thought it was going to be a lot like Roadside America (http://www.RoadsideAmerica.com) but it quickly got way to slick. With Alka-Seltzer plastered all over the site, putting it in the site's videos was overkill.

You are also right that it is the homemade quality that makes YouTube videos work. Here's one of mine:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMaTkrM2KsM

Graham

So obvious it is a "Madison Ave does Social Media" site. Check out the Privacy Policy at the bottom of the roadtrip site. Not sure that Rhett and Link wrote this one without some help from the lawyers!

General Conditions of Use
Access to and use of this website are subject to the following conditions. Please do not use this website unless you agree with these conditions. This website has been developed by Bayer Corporation (hereinafter to be referred to as BAYER) and is administrated by the same. We reserve the right to discontinue or to make partial or complete modifications to this website or to the General Conditions of Use, to our General Terms and Conditions, and to our Conditions of Sale and Delivery. Please note that we may make such changes at our own discretion and without prior announcement. We must therefore ask you, next time you visit this website, to view the conditions again and to note any changes or amendments that may have been made.

Surrender of use and benefit
All details, documents and illustrations published on this website are the sole property of BAYER. Any permission to use the same is granted on the proviso that the relevant copyright note is displayed on all copies, that such details are only used for personal purposes, that they are not exploited commercially, that the details are not modified in any way and that all illustrations gained from the website are only used in conjunction with the accompanying text.

Trademarks
All product names in upper-case letters or marked in some other way on this website are trademarks of BAYER, its subsidiaries, affiliates, licensors or joint venture partners. Any unauthorized use or abuse of these trademarks or other materials is expressly prohibited and constitutes a violation of copyright, trademark law or other industrial property rights.

Limited liability
Bayer AG has compiled the detailed information provided on this website from internal and external sources to the best of its knowledge and belief, using professional diligence. We endeavor to expand and update this range of information on an ongoing basis. The information on this website is purely for the purpose of presenting BAYER and its products and services. However, no representation is made or warranty given, either expressly or tacitly, for the completeness or correctness of the information on this website. In particular, we must ask you to be aware that this information may no longer be up to date. We therefore recommend that you check any information you obtain from this website prior to using it in whatever form. Advice given on this website does not exempt you from conducting your own checks on our latest advice - particularly our safety datasheets and technical specifications - and on our products, with a view to their suitability for the intended processes and purposes. Should you require any advice or instructions concerning our products or services, please contact us directly. Users of this website declare that they agree to access the website and its content at their own risk. Neither BAYER nor third parties involved in the writing, production or transmission of this website can be held liable for damage or injury resulting from access or the impossibility of access or from the use or impossibility of use of this website or from the fact that you have relied on information given on this website.

Websites of third-party vendors/links
This website contains links/references to third-party websites. By providing such links, BAYER does not give its approval to their contents. Neither does BAYER accept any responsibility for the availability or the contents of such websites or any liability for damage or injury resulting from the use of such contents, of whatever form. Links to other websites are provided to website users merely for the sake of convenience. Users access such websites at their own risk.

Details supplied by yourself
The user of this website is fully responsible for the content and correctness of details he or she sends to BAYER as well as for the non-violation of any third-party rights that may be involved in such details. The user gives his or her consent for BAYER to store such details and to use the same for the purpose of statistical analysis or for any other specified business purpose, unless the information involves personal details, going beyond master data or usage data (if a german subsidiary uses this text, please add: as defined in sections 5 and 6 of the German Teleservices Data Protection Act (Teledienstedatenschutzgesetz)). In particular, Bayer is entitled to use the contents of such messages, including ideas, inventions, blueprints, techniques and expertise contained therein, for any purpose, such as the development, production and/or marketing of products or services and to reproduce such information and make it available to third parties without any limitations.

International users
This website is checked, operated and updated by BAYER. It is exclusively intended for use in the United States. BAYER gives no guarantee that the details presented on this website are also correct in places outside the United States, and, in particular, that products and services will be available with the same appearance, in the same sizes or on the same conditions. Should you call up this website from a place outside the United States or download contents from such a place, please note that it is your own responsibility to ensure that you act in compliance with local legislation applicable in that place.

Products mentioned on this website may come in different packaging, in different package sizes, or with different lettering or markings, depending on the country.

In the USA the business of the Bayer Group is conducted by Bayer Corporation. Customers in the USA are requested to address to one of these entities.

Sale of BAYER Products
Our products are sold in accordance with the current version of our General Conditions of Sale and Delivery

Forward-Looking Statements
This website may contain forward-looking statements based on current assumptions and forecasts made by Bayer Group or subgroup management. Various known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors could lead to material differences between the actual future results, financial situation, development or performance of the company and the estimates given here. These factors include those discussed in Bayer’s public reports which are available on the Bayer website at www.bayer.com. The company assumes no liability whatsoever to update these forward-looking statements or to conform them to future events or developments.

Sanford Dickert

Completely agree - the video is quite funny/amusing - and the site is just a little too slick.

You hit the points which makes it fun and viral - the challenge I would ask you: what is the social imperative that would make you forward the video?

Craig

The video is really funny and like the others agree the site is way to fancy. But how much more of a home-made look and feel to the website would you like? How do you think they should redesign it to down play it from being a straight advertisement to a more fun offering for users?

Craig
www.budgetpulse.com

Leo Wurschmidt

Great video and in my opinion, vinegar-based is the best. Go North Carolina!

David - My question to you is why does it have to be homemade to be spread? A video can be successful if it hits a right cord with people. I know my friends and I talk a lot about funny commercials we have seen and heard (professionally made or not). Some examples might be the Apple commercials, Sonic commercials or the Bud Light commercials. All were funny and I have heard many people talking about them.

Sanford - You sound a lot like a sociologist. :) Why does there have to be a social imperative to desire to tell a friend? Sure, I feel compelled to tell people about injustices in Darfur, but with regards to funny videos I just want to make someone else laugh along with me. It is not imperative to want to retell a funny joke or story I just heard. I merely want to.

Tim Washer

I've been a big fan of Rhett & Link for a while. Video is funny but the fun experience crashes when we get to the corporate banner on the website. Wow! I like the design of the site, but I agree the slick Flash takes you out of the experience a bit. Maybe a simple travel blog would work better.

David Meerman Scott

I think Tim is right. The reason I don't like this is it is from the ADVERTISING playbook which assumes that you have to coerce people into doing something.

As Tim says, a simple travel blog would have been cool.

We're all advertised to thousands of times each and every day. The reason that the homemade feel works is that people crave authenticity. They don't like that over produced thing.

Even the Apple vs. Mac or the iPod "dancing to music" TV commercials don't overtly "sell" and only have on camera angle for the entire thing -- hallmarks of "homemade"

Good discussions. Thanks all.

David

Mike Lefebvre

Love the video! Love that they use an outline of California when talking about (and subsequently dissing) Florida.

Thank you for this post David. It gives me great justification for the "kitschy", "homemade" feel of my videos as well. What I once chalked up to amateur ability and less-than-professional equipment now has, in the words of Steve Martin, a special purpose!

Here's my latest. Very little corporate slickness here. All intended! Enjoy: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wEpn5wW_mdA

Richard

I don't really see what the problem is. If they didn't make it obvious they were shilling for Alka-Seltzer in these vids, people would be up in arms about how advertising 'lies and deceives'. If the site didn't look a little glossy and offer bumper stickers and other goodies, there'd be untold snark about how lame their site is.

These are hilarious videos that are part of a larger campaign, which is why the blurb on their car is made to look like an old magazine ad, and their stickers are like billboards. I applaud them their honesty and the ingenious way in which they provided branded content.

The comments to this entry are closed.

@DMScott


Your email address:


Powered by FeedBlitz

follow me


David Meerman Scott books


I want to speak at your next event!


Newsjacking!


David Meerman Scott e-books

David's iPhone and iPad apps

Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 12/2004